Lately I have been trying to apply my wing chun in a much more free form manner against an unwilling opponent. I feel I have learned a lot, but muuch of my learning has been that I am doing things wrong. My application is at fault. But it has also validated that wing chun is just fine, so far, in sparing sessions dispite what many MMA people try to preach.
So I was thinking, which parts of wing chun are invalid, assuming you take that position. Is it the striking? Do we not strike Correctly? It seems to me that many people can hit pretty good. I don't see much issue with delivering powerful blows. Though I admit not everyone has those blows. What I have found is that if you don't deliver powerful blows then your opponent won't "respect" you and will walk all over you.
Is it Bong Sau, Jut Sau, or perhaps Mun Sau? Are these inadequate? It seems to me that they tend to work well when applied in the correct manner. I admit I had some trouble with Bong Sau. But I quickly found the problem and am working on fixing it. It was a bit of a timing/engagement issue. However when applied properly it worked pretty well.
Perhaps the stances. Are the stances bad? Which one, or all of them? Does it not allow the mobility or the ability to backup our strikes or hits? The stance seemed OK. I had problems here and there in my balance. My rooting was great but it seem adequate when I needed it to be. But it could be better.
Perhaps it is engaging? This was a major factor for me, but not so much for others senior to me. I think this part is the most difficult to do correctly and I saw a lot of room for improvement.
Personally I think the tools are all valid and I think most of the MMA people have a ligit gripe. I don't think the gripe is valid when directed towards the tools wing chun has. But I do think the break down in application with many are in the application of the those tools. For me, there are many ways to apply these tools, some work and others don't. Unless you get out there and learn it, you won't be able to. But I still have a hard time understanding what exactly the MMA people feel is bad? I feel it is the implementation.