These two are charachteristicly different. It's like the 'style vs. style' arguement, ultimately it will depend on physical size and ability, understanding of the art and experience employing it.

How about WC knives vs. Jo?

(see, it's kinda bogus, huh?)

But, for the sake of it, in modern times who walks around with an 8' pole? (Escrima sticks...maybe.)

I don't train it for the 'weapon' skill of it. I train it for it's conditioning aspects, and would teach it to students at the begining of their training.