Is Wing Chun Internal?

[SimonM]

You taught him nothing. Just mouthed the same old superstitious platitudes about magical Qi larping.

[GlennR]

You taught him nothing. Just mouthed the same old superstitious platitudes about magical Qi larping.

thanks Simon... but im sure he has filled me with unlimited wisdom

[LoneTiger108]

It seems many here just love to criticize things they have no experience of, even 10 years after the discussion started

Let me ask all you scientific types a simple question...

What happens to the skin, tendons and bones of a body builder after many years of cultivating their shape and muscule tone? (without steroids!!)

What happens to the skin, tendons and bones of a Taichi practitioner after many years of cultivating their shape and muscle tone?

What is it that drives this 'body changing' process?

[GlennR]

=LoneTiger108;1115009] It seems many here just love to criticize things they have no experience of, even 10 years after the discussion started

Experienced it, trounced it... next question

Let me ask all you scientific types a simple question...

What happens to the skin, tendons and bones of a body builder after many years of cultivating their shape and muscule tone? (without steroids!!)

What happens to the skin, tendons and bones of a Taichi practitioner after many years of cultivating their shape and muscle tone?

What is it that drives this 'body changing' process?

Ok, ill bite.... do tell

[LoneTiger108]

Experienced it, trounced it... next question

Experienced it with who exactly?

Ok, ill bite.... do tell

Read it again my friend. It's a question for you to answer...

[SimonM]

Ok, ill bite.... do tell

With External: You age wither and die!!!!!

With internal: ETERNAL LIFE plus you can fly with qinggong.

[GlennR]

]Experienced it with who exactly?

Every WC internalists thats tried to tell me im missing the "internal way"

Read it again my friend. It's a question for you to answer... :eek

Ill pass..... im not really interested in the variance in skin between various people

[LoneTiger108]

I've met a few wild cases myself dude, but your negative reply is noted.

[YiQuanOne]

For all you guys that want the study, all I can say is follow the money.

Who would fund this study, how could some one benifit by telling you not to buy this drug or buy this gym equipment, they can't, people want to fund studies that sell their product.

If you don' t believe that, well good luck!

It must be nice to experence something without experenceing it.

Have fun not experenceing experence.

[GlennR]

For all you guys that want the study, all I can say is follow the money.

Who would fund this study, how could some one benifit by telling you not to buy this drug or buy this gym equipment, they can't, people want to fund studies that sell their product.

If you don' t believe that, well good luck!

It must be nice to experence something without experenceing it.

Have fun not experenceing experence.

Youve weight trained, boxed, muay thai'd and fought a lot?

[SimonM]

For all you guys that want the study, all I can say is follow the money.

Who would fund this study, how could some one benifit by telling you not to buy this drug or buy this gym equipment, they can't, people want to fund studies that sell their product.

If you don' t believe that, well good luck!

It must be nice to experence something without experenceing it.

Have fun not experenceing experence.

So.....

The skimaster is using the "big gym" money to cover up any studies demonstrating internal is better.

This reality you live in, it is not our own, is it?

[YiQuanOne]

So.....

The skimaster is using the "big gym" money to cover up any studies demonstrating internal is better.

This reality you live in, it is not our own, is it?

Go back under your rock, and troll somewhere that you have experence.

Folloooowwww thheeeee moneeeeeyyyy!!!!!!!!!

[SimonM]

There you go making assumptions again.

[YiQuanOne]

There you go making assumptions again.

If you have experence it does not show, so all I can conclude is your experence was not the same as our experence.

We went here you went there.


It is not a religion, you either got something from it or you didn't.

If you did not find anything you probably went to the wrong place.

Just because you got lost, dosen't mean everyone gets lost, check your map and see where you made the wrong turn.

[SimonM]

If you have experence it does not show, so all I can conclude is your experence was not the same as our experence.

We went here you went there.


It is not a religion, you either got something from it or you didn't.

If you did not find anything you probably went to the wrong place.

Just because you got lost, dosen't mean everyone gets lost, check your map and see where you made the wrong turn.

See to the beam in thine own eye etc etc etc.