Im looking into visiting the local WC studio next week.
Im wondering if anyone could tell me anything that differentiates Moy Yat from
other lines and what is the general thoughts of Moy Yat within the WC community.
Thanks guys
RR
Printable View
Im looking into visiting the local WC studio next week.
Im wondering if anyone could tell me anything that differentiates Moy Yat from
other lines and what is the general thoughts of Moy Yat within the WC community.
Thanks guys
RR
Just like every other lineage, I'm sure the exercises, concepts, etc, will be a little different (NOTE: not better or worse). You will see great similarities and great differences.Quote:
Originally Posted by Redrooster
I would give the school a call ahead of time, just to make sure you will be able to attend at a time to see what you are interested in seeing.
-Levi
What makes Moy Yat different?Quote:
Originally Posted by Redrooster
Nothing.
However, it seems like a lot of people ask that question more of him than they do of others. I guess you could say (in a way) this makes him "different".
Which "local WC studio" is the one you are going to visit?
Moy Yat was rather tall much taller than most other Sifu from Hong Kong ... :)Quote:
Originally Posted by Redrooster
Also he was one of the few WCK Sifu to produce very high quality pracitioners that actually had a clue and are very talented.
Case in point:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d5p-YpR2JuQ
You won't get much better WCK, anywhere.. IMNSHO... :D
Moy Yat also did his best to pass the system as it was passed to him by Ip...
Having trained at the school for years when he was alive I can attest that the best folks to come out of that school are still among the best I have ever seen anywhere...
Also he was one of the few WCK Sifu to produce very high quality pracitioners that actually had a clue and are very talented.
Case in point:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d5p-YpR2JuQ
You won't get much better WCK, anywhere.. IMNSHO...
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Anywhere? Wow-a philadelphia survey or story no doubt!! <G>
joy chaudhuri
I make no comment on whether he is good or not but there is *nothing* special about the clip you posted...just another generic performance of CK no better or worse than any of the other clips on the net.Quote:
Originally Posted by YungChun
I don't know about getting better WCK anywhere, but I do know that form has nothing to do with fighting.Quote:
Originally Posted by YungChun
Of course, all form executions are equal, none better than another.. Just as all training is equal, and all chi sao, sparring and fighting is equal.. Until one person is knocked the F#@#@$ out, that is... :D :) :cool:Quote:
Originally Posted by Nick Forrer
I can't comment on what he was most concerned with but the reality is that students in any school who are NOT self motivated will get no where fast..Quote:
Originally Posted by Ultimatewingchun
Again this is what I call taking personal responsibility for your training.. The best of the best he produced are WCK folks not JKD folks who do many different arts..Quote:
Originally Posted by Ultimatewingchun
I realize also that the school over the course of his career was a work in progress.. Things no doubt got better over time as did the skills and understanding of his students... Nevertheless the best WCK folks I have seen, my Sihings are the best I have seen anywhere and I have seen many, trained with many and shuttered at many.
We know you don't care for the traditional training but hey that's what Ip taught too... That's WCK at that time and place.. As I said later on he did come to accept--on the advice of Mickey additional modern training supplements...Quote:
Originally Posted by Ultimatewingchun
As far as asking questions... I had no problems asking him questions and Sifu had no problem answering any question I put to him.. But then he also had no problem shaking my hand either.... ;)
Things didn't stand still when you left Victor they just got better.. Use of equipment and drills, which was pushed by Mickey after you left; and the best and most knowledgeable *WCK* training and guidance from seniors in the know didn't pop out of thin air.. In my book he had the knowledge and ability to pass on this knowledge.. Now to whom and why he passed it is another issue, but it was there..
This is apparent in the skills that exist today in folks like William, Mickey, Miguel, Pete, and on and on, IMO these folks are world class WCK folks, some of the best the system has to offer.. Don't agree? Makes no difference to me and does not change my experience and opinion on the matter.. Anyone who wishes to confirm should go check out those folks..
Victor,
I am not fully aware of everything that was done.. Esp with the SSA. For the most part Mickey just broke out the equipment when he was there—when sifu was occupied in the back.. hihihih. And this period did not last forever, finally Mickey started showing up less, perhaps as he put more time in with his own group not sure what year that would be...
I also recall at that time Mickey was very much working on his own things too and he would often have me or others work with him on whatever that was. I had really good karate kicks at that time and he would have me attacking him with them for as long as I could keep it up... He would also have me gear up and then do attacks drills and try to work on his power,
release, footwork, etc...
I don't recall any of what I would call full contact sparring as I know it.. There were drills with full/hard contact, most often broken down into areas like dealing with kicks and kicking as well as striking drills using the vests, shield and leg armor.. Whipping punches on the focus glove, Pete was scary with those.. And so on, typical equipment drills, different kinds of attacks and methods depeding on who had trained what, etc.. We also used leg armor and kicking drills were done and served as a base for sticking legs stuff...
And I'll tell you most of the students I recall would have preferred to have been left to their chi sao and not had to exert themselves... It's a different kind of mentality than many other schools like in karate. This was a different animal to me..
When I chose to look for a WCK school, at that time, my goal was to experience what Bruce had.. I found myself in a karate school where there was basically full contact sparring and I was getting my azz kicked too often.. Yet those karate folks couldn't give me any kind of strategy to use to improve, and would even ask why I was using a karate block in sparring--well that's because it's what they trained there--for Christ's sake..
Why train a block that we shouldn't use? I really had issues with this kind of mentality and I still harass those types... But I had read up on Bruce and I found the stuff fascinating so.. I decided I wanted to experience what he did, or as close as possible.. In the end I did get what I wanted because to me going down to the Chinatown school, and the way Sifu taught, etc, <which I adopted!> I think I really did get close to experiencing what Bruce had and where he was coming from--quality classical WCK training, which is what I came for in the first place..
We also trained the classical stuff pretty hard.. We would often use full to near full contact in Chi Sao without pads and hit in the face/neck too, sooo to some extent even the classical training could get rough...
So, you see on the one hand you had the hard sparring but no path—and in the other you have no really hard sparring until later on but you had a path... So, you can't win for losing.. To me it was fine though because there was so much new stuff to learn---you know so I was busy trying to pick it up At the time I was honestly more interested in the Chi Sao and other WCK things I was not up to yet. I still had sparring partners left over from karate and most of the stuff I learned at the school could be tested on them. So while in the school I was more interested in material presented as is...although I wanted more than I could get... ... Other more serious folks would do much the same or compete to further their training.
I feel you though and understand what you mean in terms of well rounded training...Something I think that is happening more now in all the families as a result of other modern changes in TMA, MMA, etc...
I also appreciate the fact that some folks don't want to train full contact and that's fine... When I had my little group I told them they could sparr full contact, med, light contact, or not at all.. It's up to them... TMA like this gives folks the option of how hard to train.. The harder you train the better the results but no one need take it past where they are comfortable or want to be..
HTH
Jim
See what I mean Redrooster? Nothing at all is different.
:rolleyes:
(You guys are bush league when it comes to trolling, flaming, and nutriding.)
RedRooster
It all depends on what the Sifu at this place took from his/her training. Like any other lineage or Martial Arts camps, there are good and bad Sifu's under the single "tree". There really is no such thing as someone's ability being based solely on who they trained under. Hence, the history lesson about Sigung may or may not be relative. My Sifu, as well as other Moy Yat Sifus, have acknowledged that the training must evolve with whatever your goals and purposes are. So even if there are Sifu's in the Moy Yat family that do not put on focus mitts and head gear, there are some that do.
If there is anything unique about our family, it is what we refer to as Kung Fu life (some other families have this as well, but it is typically not a prominant part of being in the school). The Kung Fu life means that lessons may be learned outside of the Mo Kwoon. That often times "hanging out" with the Sifu, and even good Sihings, can be like an apprentice hanging out with a master.
Other than that, your approach should be to evaluate the Sifu, their students, and their school based on his/her presentation and whether their program meets your needs.
Good Luck with your kung Fu....