Quote:
Originally posted by Robert Chu
"Because BM's WCK was so lacking, and his power was coming from his shoulders, I had to correct BM's lack of stance, structure and mechanics, all of which he could not learn from Moy Yat, as a distance learning student...
The truth of the matter, Robert, in the Moy Yat lineage BM is your Sibak. The Moy Yat family is quite traditional meaning that the seniors teach the juniors and not the other way around as you describe it. Not even mentioning the fact that in the beginning of "the video" Robert is once again heard doing nothing but bad mouthing and making fun other families like WT and TWC in a very disrespectful manner. It was supposed to be a private video and there is an established pattern for Robert when it comes to things like that so no need to go too deep into that. But also in the video Robert you can be heard to be projecting yourself as an expert and know it all in comparison to the men you put down. Yet, Robert your students that chi sau with BM were all easily controlled by him because as he put it they were all lacking in forward energy. BM even said he had to also explain that to you or you might still be wondering to this day why he was able to handle them so easily. These are not things where people have to rely on the opinion and memory of others when all they have to do is look at the video. So as Robert is prone to do try as he might there is no denying that which is on tape for everyone to see. That is after his students chi sau with BM, Robert was not looking like an expert teacher but rather like a frustrated, angry and defeated man.
Quote:
If that's so, then why when Benny Meng visited with Robert, in the same video video Robert is heard saying disrepsctful things about GM Cheung, did Benny run through every one of Robert's students in Chi Sau? It wasn't even a challenge for Benny. One after the other, benny tossed them around because their WCK was so 'lacking' as Robert puts it. Robert was so frustrated he even yelled at his students "all of you should be exectuted!!" in the video. It's also funny Robert refused to touch benny's hands that day with the camera on
And, when asked how it was that Benny could handle all of his students, Benny replied "because they lack forward energy". And there's talk of Robert's Chi Sau coming from Benny, no wonder why...
This too has been pointed out by BM in which he states emphatically the money he paid Robert was not worth it. Even though you Robert claim to be an expert in the art of Gu Loa wing chun he says you could not remember all the 40 points of Gu Loa and that is why you had to continually refer to your notses and there was no demonstration of the art. Once the gu loa notes were discussed in detail the rest of the time was spent on Moy Yat wing chun. So it is kind of easy to see why there was some question as to who really benefited from that particular meeting after all was said and done and why some might question whether or not Robert's chi sau was actually coming from Benny.